Police have said they do not have enough evidence to pursue a manslaughter conviction in connection with the deaths of four people, including Bath man Mike James, at Wessex Water’s site at Avonmouth in 2020.
Mike James (64), Luke Wheaton (16), Brian Vickery (63) and Ray White (57) | Photos © Avon & Somerset Police
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) meanwhile are continuing to carry out a “robust criminal investigation” to establish if there have been any breaches of health and safety law in connection with the explosion at the water recycling centre on Thursday 3rd December 2020.
Mike James died along with Ray White from Portishead, Brian Vickery from Clevedon and teenager Luke Wheaton, from Bradley Stoke.
Since then, the Major Crime Investigation Team (MCIT) has been leading the inquiry into what caused the explosion with the help of the HSE.
In a statement on Wednesday 10th July, Avon & Somerset Police said: “Enquiries have focused on establishing whether any individuals or organisations were responsible for the explosion as well as whether any health and safety offences had been committed.
“The families of Luke Wheaton, 16, Ray White, 57, Brian Vickery, 63, and Mike James, 64, have been kept regularly updated on any significant developments.
“Detectives from MCIT and investigators from the HSE recently met with the Crown Prosecution Service to review the evidence which had been gathered.
“The decision was subsequently made that there was insufficient evidence to provide a realistic prospect of a criminal conviction for manslaughter.
“While the decision marks an end to the police-led investigation, the HSE will continue to carry out enquiries to determine whether criminal offences were committed under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.”
Detective Chief Inspector Mark Almond said: “Throughout our inquiry, the families of Luke, Ray, Brian and Mike have been firmly in our thoughts.
“The families have demonstrated great dignity and patience while we carried out our enquiries and I’d like to publicly thank them for their support and understanding over the past three and a half years.”
He added: “Inquiries of this kind are extremely complex and require the support of other agencies to gather evidence and then a variety of experts to help us interpret what that evidence tells us.
“In this case, the evidence we’ve gathered doesn’t reach the extremely high threshold to prosecute any criminal offence of manslaughter.
“We have met all the families to explain this development and to inform them of what will happen next, with HSE taking ownership of the investigation.”
HSE principal inspector Simon Chilcott said: “We have been a part of this complex inquiry from the outset. Now as the lead agency, we will continue to carry out a robust criminal investigation to establish if there have been any breaches of health and safety law.
“We are in regular contact with the families, with whom our thoughts remain.”
